‘Complete live viruses are necessary for transmission, not the fragments identified by PCR’ Study Says, Save Colorado

Man having a Nasal Swab test for Coronavirus with sign

‘Complete live viruses are necessary for transmission, not the fragments identified by PCR’ Study Says

1121 Jefferson T ; Spencer EA ; Brassey J ; Heneghan C .

  1. Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Radcliffe Observatory Quarter, Oxford, OX2 6GG
  2. Trip Database Ltd

Corresponding author:
Jefferson (tom-jefferson@conted.ox.ac.uk) Alternate corresponding author
Carl Heneghan

Professor of EBM & Director CEBM,

Nuffield Dept. of Primary Care Health Sciences,

University of Oxford

E: carl.heneghan@phc.ox.ac.uk

ciaa1764

Summary:

The reliability of RT-qPCR for assessing infectious potential of Covid-19 positives is defined by testing reference and culture specimens and their relation to patient characteristics (date and severity of symptoms, medical history) and test factors (cycle threshold).

Abstract:

Objective to review the evidence from studies relating SARS-CoV-2 culture with the results of reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and other variables which may influence the interpretation of the test, such as time from symptom onset

Methods We searched LitCovid, medRxiv, Google Scholar and the WHO Covid-19 database for Covid- 19 to 10 September 2020. We included studies attempting to culture or observe SARS-CoV-2 in specimens with RT-PCR positivity. Studies were dual extracted and the data summarised narratively by specimen type. Where necessary we contacted corresponding authors of included papers for additional information. We assessed quality using a modified QUADAS 2 risk of bias tool.

Results We included 29 studies reporting attempts at culturing, or observing tissue infection by, SARS-CoV-2 in sputum, nasopharyngeal or oropharyngeal, urine, stool, blood and environmental specimens. The quality of the studies was moderate with lack of standardised reporting. The data suggest a relationship between the time from onset of symptom to the timing of the specimen test, cycle threshold (Ct) and symptom severity. Twelve studies reported that Ct values were significantly lower and log copies higher in specimens producing live virus culture. Two studies reported the odds of live virus culture reduced by approximately 33% for every one unit increase in Ct. Six of eight studies reported detectable RNA for longer than 14 days but infectious potential declined after day 8 even among cases with ongoing high viral loads. Four studies reported viral culture from stool specimens.

Conclusion:

Complete live viruses are necessary for transmission, not the fragments identified by PCR. Prospective routine testing of reference and culture specimens and their relationship to symptoms, signs and patient co-factors should be used to define the reliability of PCR for assessing infectious potential. Those with high cycle threshold are unlikely to have infectious potential.

#COVID19 #CDC #COLORADO #DENVER #PANDEMIC #JAREDPOLIS ‘Complete live viruses are necessary for transmission, not the fragments identified by PCR’ Study Says, Save Colorado